2009 saw the first visit from newly built LNER A1 No.60163 'Tornado', which was the star guest at the Spring Steam Gala. Held across two weekends, the event saw huge crowds visit the railway to catch a glimpse of the first newly built steam locomotive since the end of steam.
The spring of 2010 saw NYMR services diverted via the Esk Valley line to Battersby whilst Bridge 30, near Goathland was replaced. SR 'Schools' No.30926 'Repton' is seen at various locations between Whitby and Battersby. 2010 saw visiting engines LNER A4 No.60019 'Bittern', GNR N2 No.1744, LNER K1 No.62005, SR BB No.34070 'Manston', LNER J72 No.69023 'Joem' and LNER A1 No.60163 'Tornado'. A photo charter is included with BR 9F No.92214 and LMS 5MT No.45428 during October 2010.
2011 marked the 175th anniversary since the opening of the Whitby to Pickering railway, throughout the year a variety of events were held to celebrate the occasion. The Spring Steam Gala featured visiting engines BR 8P No.71000 'Duke Of Gloucester' and BR 4MT No.80072, which was re-numbered to represent classmates from Whitby shed. Photo charters are included from both the spring and autumn including BR 4MT No.80072, LNER J72 No.69023 'Joem' and GWR 78xx No.7822 'Foxcote Manor'.
2012 was kick-started with resident BR 4MT No.75029 returning to traffic after overhaul at Grosmont. The Spring Steam Gala featured visiting engines BR 7MT No.70000 'Britannia' and LNER A4 No.4464 'Bittern', now running in LNER Garter Blue. Photo charters are featured from the spring and autumn including SR S15 No.825 and BR 4MT No.75029.
2013 saw the return to steam of LNER B1 No.61264 and Lambton Tank No.29, the Spring Steam Gala featured LNER B1 No.1306 'Mayflower', the only other surviving LNER B1. The 2013 season also featured visiting engine USATC S160 No.6046 which headlined at the autumn steam gala.
The 2014 Autumn Steam Gala featured visiting engines GWR 28xx No.2807 and GWR No.5029 'Nunney Castle'. Photo charters are included from the autumn and winter featuring GWR 28xx No.2807 and 0-6-0ST WD132 'Sapper'.
Sole surviving LNER K4 No.61994 arrived at the railway and hauled services throughout 2015, the autumn steam gala featured visiting engines SR WC No.34092 'City Of Wells' and SR U Class No.31806. Photo charters are featured from the spring and autumn including BR 4MT No.76079 and SR U Class No.31806.
2016 included a headline visit from freshly overhauled LNER A3 No.60103 'Flying Scotsman', making one of its first heritage railway appearances since returning to steam. 2016 also saw visiting engines BR 4MT No.76084 and GWR 78xx No.7822 'Foxcote Manor' visit for the autumn steam gala. Photo charters are featuring from the spring and autumn including BR 4MT No.76079, LMS 5MT No.45428 'Eric Treacy' and BR 4MT No.76084.
LMS 7P No.46100 'Royal Scot' opened the 2017 season, making its first visit to the railway for a weeklong event. The autumn steam gala featured visiting tank engines GWR 57xx No.7714 and GWR 51xx No.5199. A photo charter is featured with GWR 51xx No.5199.
2018 saw both LMS 5MT No.45428 'Eric Treacy' and LNER B1 No.61264 return to pre-BR liveries. The railway welcomed the return of LNER J27 No.65894 which is also featured on a photo charter.
2019 included one of the biggest autumn steam gala's the railway has ever hosted, visiting engines included GWR No.6023 'King Edward II', GWR No.6990 'Witherslack Hall', LNER K1 No.62005, LNER A4 No.60009 'Union Of South Africa' and USATC S160 No.2253.